Author: A Root Guy
Rooting your Android device can give you more control and flexibility, allowing you to customize your device and install apps that require root access. However, rooting your device also has its risks, and it's essential to choose the right rooting tool for your needs. Two of the most popular rooting tools available for Android devices are Magisk and SuperSU. In this blog post, we will compare both tools and highlight their advantages and disadvantages from a non-biased standpoint.
What is Rooting?
Rooting is the process of gaining administrative access to your Android device's operating system. By rooting your device, you can modify the system files, install custom ROMs, and customize your device in ways that are not possible with a non-rooted device. However, rooting your device can also be risky, and it's essential to proceed with caution.
What is Magisk?
Magisk is a popular rooting tool that allows you to modify your device's systemless-ly. It means that you can modify the system files without actually changing them. Magisk achieves this by using a virtual space to overlay the modified files, leaving the original system files untouched. This is a significant advantage over other rooting tools, as it allows you to use apps like Google Pay and Netflix, which are not compatible with rooted devices.
Advantages of Magisk
- Systemless Rooting: Magisk's systemless rooting method means that you can modify the system files without actually changing them. This is a significant advantage over other rooting tools, as it leaves the original system files intact.
- Magisk Modules: Magisk comes with a suite of modules that you can use to customize your device further. These modules allow you to add features like Emoji replacements, RAM management fixes, and camera2 API Enabler, among others.
- MagiskHide: Magisk's MagiskHide feature allows you to hide root access from certain apps, which is a significant advantage over other rooting tools. This feature is especially useful if you want to use apps like Google Pay and Netflix, which are not compatible with rooted devices.
- Open Source: Magisk is an open-source app, which means that you can view its source code. This is a significant advantage over SuperSU, which is a closed-source app.
Disadvantages of Magisk
- Complexity: Magisk can be more complex to use than other rooting tools, especially for beginners. It requires a more technical understanding of how Android devices work.
- Stability: Magisk can be less stable than other rooting tools, especially if you install a lot of modules.
What is SuperSU?
SuperSU is a popular rooting tool that has been around for a long time. It is a closed-source app, which means that you can't view its source code. SuperSU roots your device by altering the system files and adding new ones to the system partition. While this method is effective, it has some significant drawbacks.
Advantages of SuperSU
- Simplicity: SuperSU is a simple and easy-to-use rooting tool, making it an excellent choice for beginners.
- Stability: SuperSU is a stable rooting tool, and it's less likely to cause issues with your device.
Disadvantages of SuperSU
- Closed Source: SuperSU is a closed-source app, which means that you can't view its source code. This is a significant disadvantage, as it makes it harder to identify and fix issues.
- Google SafetyNet: SuperSU can trigger Google's SafetyNet API, which can prevent you from using apps like Google Pay and Netflix.
- No Customization: SuperSU doesn't come with a suite of modules like Magisk, which means that you can't customize your device as much.
- No Updates: SuperSU hasn't been updated in a long time, which means that it's less likely to receive security patches and updates.
Conclusion
In conclusion, both Magisk and SuperSU have their advantages and disadvantages. Magisk's systemless rooting method, MagiskHide feature, and open-source nature make it a superior choice for advanced users who want to customize their device. However, SuperSU's simplicity and stability make it an excellent choice for beginners who want to root their device without the added complexity.
